What Is a Manuscript Evaluation?
A manuscript evaluation, also called a reader report, is a professional review of your book that focuses on the overall structure, pacing, character development, and reader engagement. Instead of correcting grammar and punctuation, a manuscript evaluation takes a big-picture look at your story and identifies what’s working well—and what may be holding it back from connecting with readers.
This service is perfect for emerging authors, self-publishing writers, and experienced authors testing a new genre who want clear, constructive feedback before investing in more detailed editing services like developmental editing or copyediting.
Why a Manuscript Evaluation Matters
Getting professional feedback before editing can:
-
Save you money by ensuring you focus on the most impactful revisions.
-
Provide objective insight into your book’s strengths and weaknesses.
-
Help you understand how readers and agents will perceive your story.
-
Give you a clear roadmap for the next steps in the publishing process.
Pricing & Packages
-
Basic Evaluation – Up to 40,000 words – $300
Includes a 2–3 page written report with high-level feedback on structure, pacing, and characters. -
Standard Evaluation – Up to 80,000 words – $525
Includes a 4–6 page detailed report covering strengths, weaknesses, and specific revision suggestions. -
Extended Evaluation – Up to 120,000 words – $950
Includes a 6–8 page report, chapter-level notes, a full revision roadmap, and a 30-minute consultation. -
Premium Evaluation – Over 120,000 words – Custom Quote
Includes a tailored report, in-depth analysis, full roadmap, and a one-hour coaching session.
What You’ll Receive
-
A comprehensive written report highlighting strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities for improvement.
-
Actionable recommendations for revising your manuscript.
-
A clear, prioritized roadmap for your next steps.
-
Optional consultation call to review your feedback (Extended + Premium packages).
Who This Service Is For
-
First-time authors completing their first manuscript.
-
Self-publishing writers wanting professional insight before release.
-
Authors preparing to query literary agents or publishers.
-
Writers unsure which editing service they need next.
How the Process Works
-
Submit Your Manuscript in Word or PDF format.
-
In-Depth Review by your assigned editor.
-
Receive Your Report with targeted feedback and recommendations.
-
Optional Consultation to discuss your results and next steps.
FAQs About Manuscript Evaluation Services
Q: What is the difference between a manuscript evaluation and developmental editing?
A manuscript evaluation provides overall feedback without making edits to the text. Developmental editing involves detailed, in-text notes and structural adjustments.
Q: How much does a manuscript evaluation cost?
Pricing starts at $300, depending on manuscript length.
Q: How long does it take?
Most evaluations are completed in 2–3 weeks. Rush services may be available.
Q: Do you offer manuscript evaluations online?
Yes — Cherry Editorial serves authors worldwide through a fully digital process.
Q: Which genres do you work with?
We work with fiction, nonfiction, memoir, young adult, fantasy, and romance.